These are really comfortable. I’ve only had them for a few weeks in the spring so haven’t had too much time in them to test durability…

What I can say is they required no break in period, are really comfortable and provide just the right amount of support, cushion and traction on dirt trails.

I typically wear a 10.5 so I sized up and ordered 11. I would definitely not want them to be any smaller.

Just realized I’ve now been hiking in these sandals for 6 years, so it’s probably time to write a review. I live in AZ and hike about 20 miles a week and genuinely, these are all I want to wear on and off the trail. I switch to trail runners if it gets below 60 degrees or if I’m backpacking, but I want to be buried in these sandals. I actually have two pairs so I can wear the more worn out ones around town and save the ones with fresher tread for hiking. When one gets worn out after 2-3 seasons, I send the oldest ones in to be re-soled and rotate pairs.

This probably makes me sound like a crazy person, but these sandals are actually this good. I have super wide feet and am prone to plantar fasciitis, and they’re the most comfortable shoes I’ve ever worn. I lost one this year and Bedrock was able to sell me a single sandal instead of buying a whole other pair. Just buy them, you won’t regret it.

Since I love the standard Evo sandals as all-around footwear, I got a pair of these for hiking on rougher trails. While they're more supportive, they're also harder and more rigid, making them less comfortable. My standard Evos provide a fantastic blend of flexibility and tactile ground-feel, with durability and good traction. The 3D model is even more durable, but the footbed is rigider and thicker. Consequently, they're less comfortable, lacking the natural ground-feel. I would have rated them 3.5 if that were an option. They're well-made and highly durable. Just understand they're better for trails than as general footwear.